It depends on what the shooter is looking for inside of a 9mm carbine. For home/individual protection, the 9mm carbine is much easier to regulate and spot precise shots than a pistol. Up subsequent in my critique of the Best 9mm Carbines, if you work in law enforcement, it is https://9mmcarbine30630.full-design.com/indicators-on-ithaca-deer-slayer-you-should-know-82140628